Friday, September 09, 2011

Supercomputer predicts revolution-feeding a supercomputer with news stories could help predict major world events, according to US research.

9 September 2011 Last updated at 10:57 ET

Protesters in Egypt Sentiment mining showed a sharp change in tone around Egypt ahead of President Mubarak's ousting

Feeding a supercomputer with news stories could help predict major world events, according to US research.

A study, based on millions of articles, charted deteriorating national sentiment ahead of the recent revolutions in Libya and Egypt.

While the analysis was carried out retrospectively, scientists say the same processes could be used to anticipate upcoming conflict.

The system also picked up early clues about Osama Bin Laden's location.

Kalev Leetaru, from the University of Illinois' Institute for Computing in the Humanities, Arts and Social Science, presented his findings in the journal First Monday.
Mood and location

The study's information was taken from a range of sources including the US government-run Open Source Centre, and the Summary of World Broadcasts (now known as BBC Monitoring), both of which monitor local media output around the world.

News outlets which published online versions were also analysed, as was the New York Times' archive, going back to 1945.

In total, Mr Leetaru gathered more than 100 million articles.

Reports were analysed for two main types of information: mood - whether the article represented good news or bad news, and location - where events were happening and the location of other participants in the story.
Nautilus The Nautilus SGI supercomputer crunched the 100 million articles

Mood detection, or "automated sentiment mining" searched for words such as "terrible", "horrific" or "nice".

Location, or "geocoding" took mentions of specific places, such as "Cairo" and converted them in to coordinates that could be plotted on a map.

Analysis of story elements was used to create an interconnected web of 100 trillion relationships.
Predicting trouble

Data was fed into an SGI Altix supercomputer, known as Nautilus, based at the University of Tennessee.

The machine's 1024 Intel Nehalem cores have a total processing power of 8.2 teraflops (trillion floating point operations per second).

Based on specific queries, Nautilus generated graphs for different countries which experienced the "Arab Spring".

In each case, the aggregated results of thousands of news stories showed a notable dip in sentiment ahead of time - both inside the country, and as reported from outside.
Egypt sentiment graph Media "sentiment" around Egypt fell dramatically in early 2011, just before the resignation of President Mubarak.

For Egypt, the tone of media coverage in the month before President Hosni Mubarak's resignation had fallen to a low only seen twice before in the preceding 30 years.

Previous dips coincided with the 1991 US aerial bombardment of Iraqi troops in Kuwait and the 2003 US invasion of Iraq.

Mr Leetaru said that his system appeared to generate better intelligence than the US government was working with at the time.

"If you look at this tonal curve it would tell you the world is darkening so fast and so strongly against him that it doesn't seem possible he could survive.”

Kalev Leetaru University of Illinois

"The mere fact that the US President stood in support of Mubarak suggests very strongly that that even the highest level analysis suggested that Mubarak was going to stay there," he told BBC News.

"That is likely because you have these area experts who have been studying Egypt for 30 years, and in 30 years nothing has happened to Mubarak.

The Egypt graph, said Mr Leetaru, suggested that something unprecedented was happening this time.

"If you look at this tonal curve it would tell you the world is darkening so fast and so strongly against him that it doesn't seem possible he could survive."

Similar drops were seen ahead of the revolution in Libya and the Balkans conflicts of the 1990s.

Saudi Arabia, which has thus far resisted a popular uprising, had experienced fluctuations, but not to the same extent as some other states where leaders were eventually overthrown.
Mapping Bin Laden

In his report, Mr Leetaru suggests that analysis of global media reports about Osama Bin Laden would have yielded important clues about his location.
Bin Laden map Media reports mentioning Osama Bin Laden may have helped narrow down his location

While many believed the al-Qaeda leader to be hiding in Afghanistan, geographic information extracted from media reports consistently identified him with Northern Pakistan.

Only one report mentioned the town of Abbottabad prior to Bin Laden's discovery by US forces in April 2011.

However, the geo-analysis narrowed him down to within 200km, said Mr Leetaru.
Real time analysis

The computer event analysis model appears to give forewarning of major events, based on deteriorating sentiment.

However, in the case of this study, its analysis is applied to things that have already happened.

According to Kalev Leetaru, such a system could easily be adapted to work in real time, giving an element of foresight.

"That's the next stage," said Mr Leetaru, who is already working on developing the technology.

"It looks like a stock ticker in many regards and you know what direction it has been heading the last few minutes and you want to know where it is heading in the next few.

"It is very similar to what economic forecasting algorithms do."

Mr Leetaru said he also hoped to improve the resolution of analysis, especially in relation to geographic location.

"The next iteration is going to city level and beyond and looking at individual groups and how they interact.

"I liken it to weather forecasting. It's never perfect, but we do better than random guessing."

This news is very interesting to me because your prophet at large here invented a very similar method and one ahead of these guy's curve way back in 1975. I called it "Futurescope" and here's how it worked:

Supercomputer(s) are fed all existing literature on record in the Library of Congress going back 200 years. This includes periodicals and popular music too. Then the computer does a word check analysis of all this data seeing how many times words are being used at specific dates to see if there's any correlation between the number of times words are used and real time social behavior patterns. For instance, before the outbreak of the Civil War how often was the word "war" used in print before war actually broke out? The idea is the same as the news article today, i.e., looking for patterns to predict future events. I wrote a screenplay using this idea as a main plot for a thriller. Some day you might see WORD on your movie screens..

1 comment:

Steve Lewis said...

Recent correspondence with Kalev Leetaru-

Dear Kalev Leetaru,

I just read the news article about your supercomputer system and thought you guys should consider this method that I invented in 1975 and called it "Futurescope". My idea was using the Library of Congress's whole vast literary collection on file as data source for doing a word count for published material, periodicals, book, even popular music to see if there was a correlation between the number of times words were being used and actual social behavior. For example was the word "war" being used more and more frequently before war actually broke out in 1860 or 1917 or 1940. Is there a definite pattern to this, e.g. if the number of times the word "war" is seen in print correlates with real time events there might be some sort of critical mass type of information/social behavior signal event that can be used to predict future wars, future peace the same way. Word Count is the basis for this word predictor. I would like to know what you think of this?

best regards,

Stephen Lewis


Stephen, thanks for your note. You might check out Google's n-gram viewer (http://ngrams.googlelabs.com/), which lets you search the density of a given word or short phrase over the last 200 years, as it would let you explore many of these ideas.

~Kalev


Thanks, Kalev,

I just checked "war" and sure enough there's the spikes around the starts of WW I and II but not so much for the Civil War. "Peace" is puzzling too as it also rose in spikes in the war times. This word count method would have to be refined but I do think it holds promise. In my Futurescope system predicting the random acts of nature, seemingly impossible, could also be done by word count of seers predictions, e.g. Nostradamus, Edgar Casey, etc. to see if there's any correlation. I've attached my screenplay (unfinished because too wordy, too hard to explain the concept in film dialogue) for your amusement.

best regards,

Stephen Lewis

Steve Lewis Blog

A Biomystical Christian activist perspective on current events

We are Holy One

We are Holy One
Altarnative

Blog Archive

About Me

My photo
Prophesy bearer for four religious traditions, revealer of Christ's Sword, revealer of Josephine bearing the Spirit of Christ, revealer of the identity of God, revealer of the Celestial Torah astro-theological code within the Bible. Celestial Torah Christian Theologian, Climax Civilization theorist and activist, Eco-Village Organizer, Master Psychedelic Artist, Inventor of the Next Big Thing in wearable tech, and always your Prophet-At-Large.